Hosting a backyard bonfire on a budget? Here are frugal bonfire party favors under $3 each, plus DIY tips and packaging tricks that make cheap gifts look expensive.
I’ll be honest — the first bonfire I ever hosted, I panicked about favors two days before the party and ended up buying a bunch of overpriced glow sticks from a party store because it was all I could find. They were fine. Nobody remembered them. That’s the thing about party favors: expensive doesn’t equal memorable, and cheap doesn’t have to mean forgettable either.
If you’re planning a backyard bonfire and don’t want to blow your budget on take-home gifts, you’re in the right place.
Below are favor ideas that mostly run $1 to $3 per guest (some are practically free if you already have supplies on hand), plus a few packaging tricks that make dollar-store finds look like you spent way more than you did.
Why You Don’t Need to Spend Much on Bonfire Favors
Here’s a little secret from years of hosting on a tight budget: guests remember the feeling of a party far more than the item they walked away with. A warm fire, good food, and a small, thoughtful token at the end are plenty.
The trick is picking things that fit the vibe — cozy, outdoorsy, a little rustic — rather than chasing whatever looks fanciest on a shelf.
So before you grab your wallet, ask yourself two questions: Will this get used again? And does it fit a bonfire without me having to explain what it’s for? If the answer to both is yes, you’ve probably found a winner.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on some of the links on this website and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I believe will add value to my readers, and all opinions expressed are my own. Thank you for supporting this site.
Frugal Bonfire Party Favors That Don’t Look Cheap
1. DIY S’mores Kits in Mason Jars
Layer graham cracker pieces, mini marshmallows, and chocolate chips in a small jar (thrifted or reused from pasta sauce works fine). Tie a bit of twine and a handwritten tag around the neck. It costs pennies per jar and looks like something off Pinterest.
2. Dollar Store Roasting Sticks
Most dollar or discount stores carry basic metal skewers or extendable roasting forks. Buy a batch, wrap the handles in a strip of plaid ribbon, and you’ve got a favor guests will use at their own next cookout.
3. Painted River Rocks
If you’ve got a free afternoon, grab flat stones from your yard or a craft store and paint simple campfire designs — a flame, a tiny tent, a star. Kids especially love these as little keepsakes, and the “ingredients” cost almost nothing.
4. Hot Cocoa Cones
Cut a circle of parchment paper, roll it into a cone, fill it with cocoa mix and mini marshmallows, and staple the top shut with a ribbon loop. They stand up in a mug beautifully and cost less than the pre-made tube versions.
5. Popcorn in Stamped Kraft Bags
Plain kraft paper bags are cheap in bulk, and a rubber campfire or leaf stamp turns them into something that looks custom-made. Fill with caramel corn or plain popcorn for a snack favor guests will actually eat that night.
6. Herbal Tea Bag Bundles
Buy a box of tea bags, bundle three or four together with twine, and attach a tag that says something like “warm up by the fire.” It’s a favor that skews a little more grown-up and works especially well for a fall bonfire.
7. Mini Succulents or Cuttings
If you garden, propagate a few cuttings ahead of time in tiny cups. Succulents are nearly indestructible and make a favor that keeps growing long after the party — literally.
8. Pinecone Fire Starters
Dip dried pinecones in melted wax (you can use old candle stubs) and roll them in cinnamon or dried orange peel while the wax is still warm. Wrap in cellophane. These are genuinely useful for anyone with their own fire pit at home.
9. Printable Thank-You Tags
This one’s free if you already have a printer and cardstock. A few campfire-themed tags with a short note tied to any small item instantly make it feel intentional instead of thrown together.
10. Thrifted Enamel Mugs
Secondhand stores are full of enamel camping mugs for under a dollar. Wash them well, tie on a tea bag or hot cocoa packet, and you’ve got a favor that would cost five times as much new.
11. Marshmallow Roasting Fork Labels
If you’re already buying a bulk pack of roasting sticks, skip fancy packaging altogether and just tie on a small paper label with the date and “thanks for coming.” Simple, cheap, and it still feels personal.
12. Trail Mix in Recycled Jars
Save small jars from baby food, jam, or spices throughout the month before your party. Fill them with a homemade trail mix of pretzels, raisins, and whatever chocolate is on sale. Free packaging, homemade contents.
13. Friendship Bracelets
If you or your kids like crafting, a stack of embroidery floss makes dozens of bracelets for almost nothing. They’re an easy favor for a younger crowd and give kids something to do before the fire gets going.
14. Citronella Tea Lights
Small citronella candles are cheap when bought in bulk and double as bug repellent during the party itself — you could even use them as part of your table setup, then send guests home with one each.
15. Bandana Bundles
Cotton bandanas run under a dollar apiece at craft stores. Fold one around a small treat, tie with jute string, and it becomes a rustic, reusable favor guests can use as a napkin, headband, or dog bandana later.
16. Recipe Cards for S’mores Twists
Print a few fun variations on classic s’mores (peanut butter cup, cookie butter, fruit-filled) on small cards. Combine with a couple of ingredients if your budget allows, or hand them out on their own as a sweet little extra.
17. Seed Packets
A packet of wildflower or herb seeds costs next to nothing when bought in bulk and gives your bonfire a “plant something and remember us” angle. Great for a spring or early summer gathering.
Frugal Packaging Tricks That Upgrade Any Favor
- Twine and brown paper beat plastic every time. They’re cheaper, and they automatically read as rustic rather than budget.
- Buy tags and ribbon in bulk off-season. Craft stores mark these down heavily right after major holidays.
- Reuse what you already have. Baby food jars, spice jars, and even clean tin cans work as containers if you dress them up a little.
- Handwrite instead of printing when you can. It costs nothing and somehow always reads as more thoughtful.
- Group favors into one basket instead of individual bags. Letting guests pick their own combination cuts down on how much you need to buy of each item.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much should I budget per guest for bonfire favors?
Most of the ideas above land between $0.50 and $3 per person, especially if you’re buying supplies in bulk or reusing containers you already have.
Do I really need to give out favors at a bonfire party?
No — favors are a nice touch, not a requirement. If your budget is tight, a simple thank-you as guests leave is more than enough.
What’s the cheapest bonfire favor on this list?
Painted rocks, printable tags, and trail mix in recycled jars tend to cost the least, since you’re mostly paying for ingredients or supplies you may already own.
Can I make these favors ahead of time?
Yes, and I’d recommend it. Anything involving wax, painting, or drying (like the pinecone fire starters) needs a day or two, so start assembling favors about a week before your party.
What if I have a mixed group of kids and adults?
Lean toward favors like s’mores kits, trail mix, or hot cocoa that work for any age, and set aside a separate basket of glow items or bracelets for the kids specifically.
Final Thoughts
A great bonfire doesn’t need a big favor budget — it needs good company, a warm fire, and maybe a little something small to send everyone home with a smile.
Pick two or three ideas from this list, lean on what you already have around the house, and you’ll end up with favors that feel a lot more expensive than they were.
What’s your go-to cheap party favor? I’d love to hear what’s worked for your own backyard gatherings.
You May Be Interested In: