Are you looking for the best places to sell baseball cards? Yes? Then you’ve come to the right place. Here are some of the best places to sell Baseball cards for cash near me or online.
According to Verified Market Research, the global Sports Trading Card Market was valued at $7878.16 million in 2021 and is projected to reach $20,480.66 million by 2030.
There are different types of sports trading cards available. Baseball cards are one of the most common sports cards. The front of the card features a photograph of the player and identifying information such as the player’s name and team affiliation, among other things.
Perhaps, you’re a baseball maniac who loves to collect Baseball cards. Or maybe someone in your family has given you some Baseball cards as a present. You might be looking for the best places to sell baseball cards for cash.
Fortunately, there are many places to sell baseball cards for cash near you and online. In this article, I’ll feature some of the best places to sell Baseball cards for maximum profit.
What Are the Most Valuable Baseball Cards?
It’s essential to learn about the most valuable baseball cards while you’re trying to sell Baseball cards. Perhaps, you’ve one in your collection.
Here are some of the most valuable baseball cards:
- 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle (Sold for $12,600,000)
- 1909-11 T206 White Border Honus Wagner (Sold for $7,250,000)
- 1916 (M101-5) Sporting News Babe Ruth Rookie Card (Estimated Value: $1,350,000)
- 1916 (M101-4) Sporting News #151 Babe Ruth Rookie Card (Estimated Value: $1,350,000)
- 1909-11 T206 Ty Cobb Tobacco (Ty Cobb Back): Estimated Value $1,100,000
To learn more about the most valuable baseball cards, check out the list of OldSportsCards.com.
Where To Sell Baseball Cards Online?
Selling baseball cards online is a convenient way. You can sell from the comfort of your home and to millions of buyers.
Here are some of the best places to sell baseball cards online.
eBay is one of the oldest marketplaces to sell almost anything, from homemade goods to used or unused items from your closet. It’s one of the best places to sell Baseball cards online. According to Verified Market Research, eBay is emerging as the largest platform for selling sports trading cards.
Many people love to visit the eBay marketplace to buy sport trading cards, including Baseball. You can list your baseball cards on the eBay marketplace to sell to prospective buyers. eBay allows you to list 250 items for free each month. Once your item sells, they charge 10-15% of the final value.
When you price your Baseball cards for sale, consider selling and shipping fee. It’ll help you to make a profit by selling baseball cards at the eBay marketplace.
You’re not the only person selling baseball cards on the eBay marketplace. You have to compete with other sellers. You’ll have to create SEO-optimized listings on eBay so prospective buyers and collectors can find your listing on the eBay marketplace. Moreover, it’s advisable to price your cards properly.
- 250 Free listings each month.
- More than 140 million buyers.
- Set your price.
- Payouts are sent directly to your bank account.
- Charge 10-15% of the final value.
- $0.35 Insertation fee per listing.
- Fierce competition.
2. Dean’s Cards
When it comes to selling baseball cards online, Dean’s Cards is one of the best options. It sells over 1,000 vintage baseball cards daily and maintains an inventory of over one million cards. That makes it the largest online vendor for vintage cards.
Not only do Dean’s Cards sell vintage cards, but they also buy hundreds of sports card collections every year. Dean’s Cards says that they can usually pay more money for your vintage cards than you would get elsewhere because they sell directly.
Dean’s Cards buy baseball cards from 1969 and older. Moreover, they also buy most complete sets through 1985.
To get started, you’ll have to fill out an online form. After that, mail your collection to the Dean’s Cards. The company’s bid software will generate an offer that’s based on the current market prices and demand. You’ll get their best offer upfront. It’s up to you whether you accept the offer or not. If you’re not satisfied with the offer, they’ll mail your collection back to you.
According to Dean’s Cards, more than 80% of sellers accept their offer.
- The selling process is straightforward.
- They buy directly from you.
- Always pay top dollar.
- Contact them via email or call.
- Only buy baseball cards from 1969 and older.
- You can’t bargain with them.
eBid is one of the best places to sell baseball cards online. It’s one of the best alternatives to eBay. eBid allows you to sell stuff in over 25,000 categories, including Sports Memorabilia & Cards. It has a 4.1 rating out of 5 on Trustpilot. Moreover, it has been around since 1999.
To get started, you’ll have to create an account. After that, you’ll have to upgrade your account from Free to either:
- Silver: Allows you to list items for free with a 5% final value fee.
- Gold or Platinum: Allows you to list items for free. Also, you don’t have to pay any final value fee.
Due to eBid’s low fee, you can consider using this marketplace to sell baseball cards.
- Allows you to sell in over 25,000 categories.
- Low fees.
- Easy to list items for sale.
- Have to purchase a Gold subscription if you don’t want to pay a selling fee.
4. Just Collect
Just Collect is another place to sell baseball cards for cash. They’re willing to buy sports cards from 1979 or earlier. However, they do buy select modern sports cards from 1980 or later.
To start the selling process, you can use the free appraisal form. You can either mail your collection to them or visit one of their appraisal locations to sell your baseball cards. They’ll pay for shipping if your collection is worth a lot. Moreover, they’ll pay for return shipping.
If you live near one of their appraisal locations, you can call their team to set up an appraisal appointment. Once they inspect your collection, they’ll make you a cash offer within 24 hours.
- You can sell in person or mail your collection.
- They’ll pay for shipping.
- They’ll come to your location for appraisal.
- You can’t bargain with them.
- Only buys select modern sports cards.
5. Blowout Cards Forum
As the name suggests, Blowout Cards Forum is a forum where people discuss buying, selling, and trading baseball cards. You can consider using this forum to sell your baseball card collection to potential buyers.
You can participate in baseball cards discussion or list your baseball card collection on the forum. Whoever is willing to purchase your collection can reach out to you. Also, you’ll be able to set your price.
- No listing or selling fees.
- A wide range of targeted buyers.
- You’ll have to control payment and shipping.
Webstore is an online auction site that allows you to sell stuff in different categories, including Sports Memorabilia & Cards. You can sell your baseball card collection efficiently. The plus point of this online auction site is there are no listing or selling fees.
It has a 4 rating on Trustpilot, which is remarkable. You can trust this online auction marketplace to sell your baseball cards.
You might think you can’t sell baseball cards at a fixed price as it’s an auction site. The good news is Webstore also allows you to sell baseball cards at a fixed price.
- No listing or selling fees.
- Ability to sell at an auction or fixed price.
- All transactions on Webstore are handled directly between the Buyer and Seller.
Reddit is a website where people can submit content like text posts, images, videos, and links. You can consider it as a social media or forum. It’s one of the best places to sell baseball cards to potential buyers.
Reddit users can create subreddits on different topics. Subreddits are like Facebook groups where people can post text messages, images, and videos.
When you’re looking to sell baseball cards, a subreddit called r/baseballcards is one of the best options. This subreddit has over 72,000 collectors. On this subreddit, people discuss sports cards and memorabilia collections. You’re allowed to share sports cards & collectibles, news, polls, and memorabilia. However, you’re not allowed to share eBay auctions. Also, this subreddit has other rules.
- No listing or selling fees.
- Quick sale opportunity.
- Millions of users.
- You’ll have to maintain rules. Otherwise, you’ll be kicked out of the subreddit.
- You’ll have to handle payment and shipping.
8. DA Card World
DA Card World is a well-known site to sell sports cards, including baseball. DA Card World is one of the best places to sell stuff like:
- Sports/Entertainment Boxes & Cases
- Modern Sports Card Singles
- Gaming Boxes & Singles
- Vintage Cards, Boxes, & Sets
- Autographed Sports Memorabilia
- Comic Books
- Video Games
- Vintage Toys
You can start the selling process by emailing them at [email protected] or calling their Customer Support at 1-888-440-9787! Also, you can consider filling out their contact form to sell your baseball cards.
DA Card World offers multiple payment methods, including cash, PayPal, and check. They’ll pay 95% of buying price if they come to pick up everything at your house to cover their expenses.
- Quick sale.
- You can sell a wide range of sports card collections.
- Multiple payment methods.
- They’ll deduct 5% from the buying price if they come to pick up your collection.
As the name suggests, SportsCardPro is a free online marketplace to sell sports cards. You can consider selling your baseball collection through this marketplace.
To get started, you’ll have to create a listing. There are no listing fees involved. However, you’ll have to pay a 2.9% payment processing fee plus a $0.30 selling fee. You’ll get paid via PayPal.
- A dedicated marketplace to sell sports cards.
- No listing fees.
- PayPal payment method.
- Easy to list items.
- Only supports buyers and sellers in the USA and Canada.
- You’ll have to pay a selling fee and payment processing fee.
10. COMC (Check Out My Collectibles)
COMC is one of the best marketplaces to sell baseball cards and collectibles. It’s pretty convenient to sell baseball cards on this marketplace.
To get started, you have to create an account. After that, you can send your baseball card collection to them. COMC will allow you to set your asking price and respond to potential buyers.
Once your cards sell, you can choose how you would like to get paid. There are several ways to withdraw your earnings, such as:
- Convert store credit into cash.
- Redeem store credit to buy sealed boxes and cases.
- Use store credit to buy other trading cards or collectibles.
COMC will charge a selling fee. To know more about its selling rates, visit its Selling Rates page.
- Advertise your items for sale.
- Package / Ship your items securely.
- Store/Insure your items.
- Provides customer service.
- They’ll charge a selling fee.
Bonanza is another place where you can sell baseball cards. It’s an alternative to eBay, Amazon, and Etsy. It has more than 25,000 sellers, which makes it less competitive than eBay.
Bonanza offers two ways to sell items, such as:
- Marketplace: You can list your baseball cards on the marketplace.
- Webstore: You can open up an online store. However, you don’t have to use this option to sell baseball cards.
Bonanza doesn’t charge a listing fee. However, they charge a selling fee of 3.5%. Always keep in mind the selling fee while pricing your cards.
- Google integration.
- No listing fees.
- Less competitive than eBay, Amazon, or Etsy.
- There is a selling fee involved.
12. Kruk Cards
Kruk Cards is another place specializing in buying baseball and other sports cards. It has been buying and selling since 1987. They buy everything from one autographed card to entire warehouses full of inventory.
When you bring your collection to them, they’ll assess your collection and quote you an offer. They always offer the best and most fair prices for collections.
Kruk Cards recommend sellers make an appointment. It’s because they don’t always have someone in-house with the ability to purchase cards. Also, they advise preparing a list of the highlights of your collection.
- They buy all collections large and small.
- Quick payment.
- You may not get high value as they’ll sell them later.
Etsy is an online marketplace well-known for buying and selling handmade and vintage items. You can consider using this marketplace to sell baseball cards.
You can create a listing to sell your baseball cards. However, you’ll have to pay $0.20 per listing. Moreover, there is a transaction and payment processing fee involved.
- Reputable marketplace with millions of buyers.
- Easy to list baseball cards.
- Allows you to sell privately to a particular buyer.
- There is a listing, transaction, and payment processing fee involved.
14. The Cardboard Connection
The Cardboard Connection is a company that buys sports cards and collectibles directly from buyers. This company has facilitated the sale of over a million dollars worth of sports cards and collectibles. They purchase baseball cards, football cards, basketball cards, hockey cards, etc.
You may get little value for cards from the 1980s and 1990s. Their buyers are mainly looking for vintage cards from before 1974.
You can start the selling process by filling out an online form on the website. The Cardboard Connection will refer you to one of its industry-leading buying partners.
After submitting the form, you’ll be contacted by the company or/and one or more of its highly-respected network of buying partners in 1-2 business days to find out more about your collection and start the selling process.
- Directly buys from the sellers.
- Match you with one or more highly-respected networks of buying partners.
- Most cards from the 1980s and 1990s have little value.
15. 2nd Markets
2nd Markets is one of the best places to sell baseball cards with over 30 years of experience buying from the public. According to the 2nd Markets, they’re a top baseball card buyer on the internet.
They buy large collections, not single items or small collections unless they’re valuable. If you have got some modern sports cards for sale, use one of the places above.
- Directly buys from you.
- Free shipping.
- They don’t buy single items or small collections unless they are very valuable.
16. Heritage Auctions
As the name suggests, Heritage Auctions is the world’s largest collectibles auctioneer. It’s the best place to auction numismatic collections, comics, fine art, books, luxury accessories, real estate, and memorabilia from film, music, history, and sports.
Heritage Auctions always hunt for quality vintage memorabilia and sports cards to purchase or auction. You can call or email them if you would love their experts to determine the best options for your collections.
- The world’s largest collectibles auctioneer.
- Millions of bidders.
- Charges high fees.
17. Beckett Marketplace
Beckett Marketplace is one of the best places to sell baseball cards along with other sports cards. You can sell your baseball card collections by becoming a dealer at the Beckett Marketplace.
Beckett Marketplace dealers reach over 20 million collectors each month. Moreover, you’ll get access to a powerful accelerator tool that will allow you to quickly scale up your business. However, you’ll have to pay a 5% fee of the asking price.
- Millions of collectors.
- Easy to list items.
- Targeted audience.
- Charges a 5% fee on the asking price.
Where To Sell Baseball Cards Near Me?
Although selling baseball cards online is convenient, you may love to sell them locally. The most significant benefit of selling baseball cards locally is getting paid on the spot. Also, you don’t have to handle shipping.
Here are some of the best places to find local collectors for baseball cards.
Craigslist is a free classified advertisement site. It’s one of the best places to find potential buyers for baseball cards.
You can create a listing on this platform. It’s free to list items on Craigslist. Moreover, you don’t have to pay any selling fee either. However, you’ll have to handle payment and shipping.
Related Article: 30 Sites Like Craigslist To Sell & Buy Used Stuff
19. Facebook Marketplace
As you might know, Facebook is the world’s largest social media platform. It has a section called “Marketplace,” where you can buy and sell stuff locally.
Facebook allows you to list your items on the marketplace for free. It’s a great option if you want to target a specific location. However, you’re responsible for handling payment and shipping.
20. Local Card Shops
A local card shop is another option for selling baseball cards locally. However, you may not see many local card shops nearby. If you do have a local card shop nearby, ask them if they’re willing to purchase baseball cards.
How do you find local card shops? Nowadays, it’s pretty easy to locate shops around us. All you have to do is search on the internet by typing “baseball card stores near me” or “sports card stores near me.” If there are any stores nearby that buy baseball cards, the search engine will show you.
Please note that you may not get the highest price for your baseball cards by selling them to local card shops. It’s because local card shops purchase cards at a lower price so that they can sell them at a higher price.
21. Pawn Shops
Pawn shops are one of the best places to sell collectibles and antiques locally. However, not all of them buy baseball or sports cards. For that reason, you should call ahead or visit pawn shops to inquire if they buy baseball cards.
How do you find pawn shops nearby? You can search on the internet by typing “pawn shops nearby.” You’ll get a list of pawn shops in your area with contact information.
You’ll get paid on the spot when you sell to pawn shops. The drawback is they won’t offer the best price for your collections. As you might know, pawn shops buy things to resell them for a profit.
How do I determine the value of my baseball cards?
Before selling your baseball card collections, you need to determine the value. If you don’t know the value of your baseball cards, you’ll end up selling your cards for pennies.
You should consult an expert who can determine the value of your baseball cards. In that case, Heritage Auctions experts will help you out. Also, the online price guides can come in handy to determine the value of your baseball cards. The value of baseball cards depends on several factors, including the player, the card’s condition, rarity, and age.
The most valuable sports cards and memorabilia are:
- Vintage sports items from Hall of Fame players
- Sports card through 1969
- Some modern trading cards
- Player autographs
- Game-used items
How should I prepare my baseball cards for sale?
It’s essential to prepare your baseball cards for sale. Here are a few tips to prepare your baseball cards for sale:
- Organize Your Collection: It’s important to organize your card collection by date, player name, or condition. It’ll help you to find specific cards when you’re ready to sell them.
- Separate Cards: It’s important to separate your individual cards from boxed cards or sealed card collections. You can’t sell boxed cards or sealed card collections individually. They are typically sold as complete sets.
- Research the Value: As I mentioned earlier, it’s important to determine the value of your baseball cards to make maximum profit. In that case, you can consult an expert or use online price guides.
After doing all of these things, you can choose a selling platform. It depends on you how you want to sell baseball cards. If you want a convenient way, choose an online marketplace. If you want to sell baseball cards locally, there are options available.
As you can see, there are many places to sell baseball cards online and locally. There are marketplaces to sell a large collection of cards as well as small.
You’ll get high value for vintage cards. It doesn’t mean you can’t make money selling modern baseball cards. The fact is modern baseball cards don’t have high value except for a few of them.
What do you think about these places to sell baseball cards? Have you ever sold baseball cards? Let me know in the comment!